Alton Zenon III

January 30, 2024

The Future of Marketing with Zapier’s CMO: Demand Creation Over Demand Capture

AI's influence on internet search has reshuffled marketing tactics. Zapier's CMO offers predictions on what's to happen in 2024 and how to prepare.

If you’re reading this, you’re probably well aware that the marketing playing field has been slowly but surely resetting in recent years. That reset button was pushed particularly hard in the last 12 months with the injection of generative AI into the heart of internet search (Google’s Search Generative Experience) and social media posts getting more prominence than ever before (Google Perspectives.)

The tried-and-true SEO and organic traffic acquisition tactics that worked well for years have been flipped. And for the first time in a long time, many seasoned marketers are wondering: “What do I do now?”

A shot of Zapier CMO Kieran Flanagan with glasses head turned to the right. He wears a headset, seemingly speaking before a crowd
Kieran Flanagan

Kieran Flanagan, CMO at Zapier and former senior VP of marketing at HubSpot, is one such marketing pro. He spent some time ruminating over this question and he has two major suggestions for his colleagues. The first is to focus on more demand creation over demand capture. Tip two: dust off your marketing 101 skills to refocus on the fundamentals like branding and generating hype. Think less about the “science” behind the numbers and more about being a creative powerhouse like Don Draper (just way less toxic as a person.) 

Marketers can reinvest in the science of marketing more with time as Google SGE is understood a little better, Flanagan said. He also offers a prediction on what a 2.0 version of Google Ads might look like within SGE and how companies could take advantage of paid ads within it. 

Check out Flanagan’s full musings below.

How has marketing shifted in recent years?

Marketing is both demand creation and demand capture. How do we create demand for our products? How do we also capture existing demand for our product? 

Over the last 15 or so years, everyone's become accustomed to marketing being able to capture the existing demand. Prior to that, marketing was always seen as a cost center. Demand capture was awesome because it helped marketers get a seat at the revenue table. We had analytical models to help us clearly articulate the return on our work. “Here's the amount of money that I'm spending on this, here's the amount of demand I've acquired, and here’s what it's worth.” This is regardless of whether it’s search, paid, or whatever it may be. 

This was the golden era of demand capture and we were lucky to be in it. 

But now, we need to swing back to demand creation: social media content, YouTube videos, podcasts, and sources like that.

What does shifting back to demand creation look like in practice?

The demand capture era is under pressure right now from things like cookies, AI, and even the changes that Apple and Google made to their email systems that make it harder to trust email metrics. So swinging back to demand creation is necessary. If you speak to a lot of marketers, there is a group who perform marketing through scientific demand capture — even me. I built my career around demand capture and I'm really cognizant of that. So I've tried to swing much more heavily into demand creation over the years. 

That means relearning some of the fundamentals of marketing: positioning, branding, creating awareness. A lot of marketers need to relearn the fundamentals. 

All of this gets back to having incredible positioning. One of my heroes is the founder of Red Bull. People may not know this but Red Bull has had the same strapline since 1987: “Red Bull gives you wings.” It took one of the co-founders, who was working with an agency, a year and a half and 50+ campaigns to decide on that strapline. And they've used it ever since.

We likely need to go back to when positioning won and dominated markets. That’s why we have shows about (M)ad men because they were the market creators. 

We will also need to lean into things that are harder to measure, like influencer marketing and collaborating with creators. I think that over time, creators will become a much bigger part of nearly all markets. There are maybe some B2B markets where creators will never be a big thing because they're just too boring. But overall, creators could dominate a lot of marketing because they are just better at creating content. And a lot of platforms are much more motivated to elevate creators over brands. 

What are your predictions on how AI-infused searches might evolve?

I'm pretty bullish on Google creating a 2.0 version of Ads, even if clicks get cannibalized. Over time, Google could make a better AI search experience where people are still using search but they're not clicking through the publishers. Google can still use those search interactions with AI to figure out an ad model where brands pay for exposure within that AI conversation. 

They're trying that now. I don't think the ads are very good. They're going to have to figure out a better UX experience. 

If they do figure out a second version of Ads that is deeply integrated into AI, they can still have ways for brands to pay for ads within a conversational experience and get those paid clicks through to the publisher site. Users would be encouraged to click on things that are deeply integrated into that conversation but they’re actually surfaced through a paid publisher. If that is the case, organic clicks will go way down since most people don't need to click through to the publisher.

What’s also likely: I suspect that entire transactions will be done through AI. You can buy something or sign up for something as a lead, all through AI. But you will have to pay as a brand to integrate into the experience. You will have to pay for that transaction to happen in AI. 

80% of all searches on Google are under-monetized or not monetized at all. So AI actually might help Google monetize all of those searches in a much better way.

Sign up for our upcoming webinar — The Paradigm Shift in SEO: How Marketers Can Prepare — to learn even more!

More of the latest & greatest

View All Blogs

Scaling AI for the Enterprise: How Marketing Leaders Drive Impact

High-performing marketing teams are scaling AI with structure and strategy. Learn how CMOs can lead the way to drive organization-wide impact.

July 1, 2025

|

Megan Dubin

Read this blog

Reflections from Cannes: Why Brand and People Still Matter Most in the Era of AI

At Cannes Lions 2025, one truth stood out: brand, trust, and authenticity are making a powerful comeback.

June 24, 2025

|

Loreal Lynch

Read this blog

Interactive Tool: Benchmark Your AI in Marketing Strategy

Discover your marketing team's AI maturity. Benchmark your strategy, compare with peers, and uncover gaps with an interactive tool.

June 17, 2025

|

Megan Dubin

Read this blog
Jasper Closing CTA
Share
Start Free Trial
Get A Demo

Start creating with Jasper today

https://www.jasper.ai/blog/demand-creation-over-demand-capture